How to Conduct an Effective Brand Reputation Analysis 

Think of your brand reputation like a personal reputation - people naturally gravitate toward those who are trustworthy, reliable, and genuine. The same goes for brands. 

But a good reputation isn’t just about avoiding bad press - it’s about acknowledging how people see your brand, and ultimately shaping that perception. That’s where a brand reputation analysis comes in. It helps you understand what people think, what’s working, and what needs fixing - to steer direction for how you should approach your paid media efforts.

What is a Brand Reputation Analysis?

Before purchasing, most customers conduct research on not just the product they're buying, but also the brand behind it. They'll scour online for reviews, and opinions, on platforms like Google, Yelp, Trustpilot or even Reddit. And if these opinions are mostly negative, chances are they’ll go with your competitor instead.

A brand reputation analysis helps uncover what people are saying, both good and bad. By gathering insights from social media, review sites, and news articles, businesses can use this feedback to build a stronger reputation, address concerns, and create marketing campaigns that connect with their audience.

Understanding the Three Levels of Reputation Analysis

Not all social proof is created equal. A press mention in Forbes carries far more weight than a random customer review. However, that doesn’t mean press is the only thing that matters - every review, comment, and discussion about your brand influences public perception.

Some signals, like social media comments and forum discussions, provide a real-time pulse on audience sentiment. So while a glowing feature in a major publication might look impressive, it won’t tell you how people actually feel about your brand right now. A viral tweet or a heated Reddit thread? That can shift how people perceive you overnight.

This three-level framework helps break down the different layers of reputation analysis - showing how press coverage, customer reviews, and social media all shape consumer trust.

1. Press Coverage (Highest Level of Social Proof)

Nothing boosts your brand's credibility faster than being featured in major publications like Forbes, The New York Times, or Vogue. When a trusted media outlet talks about your business, it signals to customers that you're the real deal.

But press coverage isn’t just about bragging rights - it’s a trust accelerator. It positions your brand as an industry leader, making potential customers, especially those over 40, more likely to choose you over competitors. After all, if Forbes or Vogue vouches for you, why wouldn’t they?

‍

2. Review Sites & Forums (Customer-Generated Reputation)

Sometimes, buyers trust fellow consumers more than journalists or industry insiders.

Why? Because blogs, review platforms, and online communities like Reddit and Trustpilot provide raw, unfiltered opinions that feel truly genuine.

While press coverage builds authority, reviews and discussions shape trust - especially for younger consumers. A strong reputation on these platforms can sway potential buyers just as much as being featured in Forbes.  

3. Social Media (Most Timely and Dynamic Analysis)

Social media interactions - love them or hate them - offer a real-time look at what people really think. Customers react instantly to campaigns, products, and experiences, making platforms like Instagram, TikTok, and Twitter invaluable for monitoring sentiment and adjusting strategies.

A brand reputation analysis looks at all three levels of social proof and understands how they come together to shape consumer perception. By examining each layer, businesses can identify gaps, risks, and opportunities for improvement and growth.

Step 1: Assess Your Brand’s Press Coverage (High-Authority Social Proof)

First up, let’s look at the most powerful form of social proof—press coverage. What are news sites saying about your brand? A quick search can reveal a lot.

Here’s how to assess your brand’s media presence:

• Google your brand name + "news" and switch to the News tab
• See who’s talking about your brand - scan articles, headlines, and sources
• Take note of press mentions - which publications have featured you?
• Assess the sentiment - is the coverage positive, negative, or neutral?

Don’t have any press mentions yet? No problem! Try pitching to industry blogs, work with PR agencies, or repurpose high-quality blog content into press-style articles. 

You can also collaborate with journalists through Qwoted, Featured, Dot Star Media, and SourceBottle. These tools connect brands with reporters who need sources, making it easier to get featured in reputable publications.

Step 2: Review Sites, Blogs & Forums (Understanding Customer Sentiment)

Once you’ve gone through your press coverage, it’s time to dig into what real customers are saying. This means checking:

• Review sites like Trustpilot, BBB, and My Subscription Addiction.
• Reddit & forums, where people don’t hold back.
• Amazon Q&A & competitor reviews, which reveal common objections.

During your analysis, looking for the following:

Common complaints or praise:

Do people consistently say your product is too expensive? Are they raving about fast shipping? Look for recurring pros and cons as these affect conversion rates.

Sentiment trends on Reddit & forums:

Reddit and industry forums can be brutal, but they’re also a goldmine for unfiltered feedback. Search for your brand (or competitors) in relevant subreddits and read through the posts. Are people enthusiastically recommending your product, or are they warning others to stay away?

Amazon Q&A & competitor reviews:

Even if you don’t sell on Amazon, the Q&A section and reviews are packed with customer concerns. If multiple people ask, "Does this come with a warranty?", you now know to include that information on your website, or other marketing materials.

Step 3: Analyse Social Media Engagement

Social media isn’t just for catching up on your high school classmates' latest political rants. It’s also a major trust signal for brands. Many customers check platforms like Instagram and TikTok before making a purchase, so how a brand shows up there matters.

Type in the brand and analyse the following: 

Post engagement:

Are people liking, commenting, and sharing the content, or does it sit with barely any interaction? If certain posts are gaining traction, see what’s working and replicate them.

Brand interaction with customers:

Beyond post performance, look at how the brand engages with its audience. Is communication a two-way street, or do they post and disappear? Brands that ignore customer interactions risk leaving the comments section open to unhappy customers and negative feedback.

Answering questions, resharing user-generated content, and responding to comments can turn followers into customers.

Step 4: Monitor TikTok as a Search Engine

TikTok is a major search engine for many demographics, often trumping mainstream search engines like Google. Users turn to TikTok to look up product reviews, brand reputation, and real customer experiences before purchasing. And even if a brand isn't on TikTok, chances are they're being talked about on the platform.

Start by doing a simple search:

• Look up the brand name + “review” to see what pops up.
• Look for common objections, concerns, and praises that keep showing up in TikTok discussions.
• If you’re not being talked about, check competitor reviews to understand industry sentiment.

Review the content and the comment sections. Sometimes, you’ll learn a great deal more from how users react to a video rather than the video itself.

Step 5: Use Reputation Insights in Your Ads & Marketing Materials

You’ve collected data from press mentions, customer reviews, Reddit discussions, and social media comments. Now it’s time to put them to work in your next campaign. Below are practical ways to turn this data into high-performing ads and marketing materials.

Press Mentions 

Here’s how to use press mentions to reinforce your brand’s authority, and gain huge trust signals:

• Create press screenshot ads – Feature a snippet of the article in Facebook, Instagram, or TikTok ads.
• Use publication logos on your website, email signature, and marketing materials.
• Highlight press quotes in social media posts, landing pages, and email campaigns.

‍

Review Sites 

Customer reviews build trust faster than brand messaging alone. Instead of just telling people your product is great, let your customers do it for you:

• Repurpose positive reviews – Take Trustpilot or BBB reviews and overlay them on product images.
• Turn customer quotes into testimonial ads – Feature real words from satisfied buyers in social posts and emails.
• Use five-star reviews in carousel ads – Show multiple customer experiences in a swipeable format.

Twitter-Style and Reddit-Style Ads

Some of the best ads feel like regular social posts. That’s why Twitter-style and Reddit-style ads work so well - they blend in naturally.

• Twitter-Style Ads – Brands turn real (or recreated) tweets into ads, often pairing them with user-generated content (UGC) to highlight customer experiences or witty brand moments.
• Reddit-Style Ads – If your audience is on Reddit, use it. Brands repurpose positive comments or common concerns from Reddit discussions, turning them into ad creatives that address real conversations.

Beyond marketing, reputation insights can help you fine-tune how you run your business. They can help show you what’s working and what needs fixing.

Here are a few examples:

• Too many shipping complaints? Maybe it’s time to streamline your process or be clearer about delivery times on your site.
• Hearing the same complaints about customer service? Look for patterns, improve response times, and make FAQs or support easier to access.

Ultimately, your reputation isn’t just something to monitor - it’s a goldmine of insights that can help you improve your brand from the inside out.

Step 6: Monitor & Manage Your Comment Section (Hidden Reputation Killer)

Even a single negative comment left unchecked can snowball into a full-blown reputation crisis before you know it. But if you handle them right, they can actually work in your favour.

Here’s how to keep your comments section under control:

• Don’t ghost your audience – Jump on common objections and clear up any misunderstandings with a quick, professional response.
• Encourage the good vibes – Pin positive comments and engage with supportive users. The more you highlight good feedback, the more of it you’ll get.
• Know when to hit delete – There’s a difference between a legitimate complaint and a straight-up attack. If a comment is defamatory or harmful, consider removing it.

Handled the right way, your ad comments can become a trust-building tool that reassures potential customers and even helps boost conversions.

Own the Conversation with MagicBrief

Your brand’s reputation isn’t just something to monitor. It’s a powerful marketing tool. Every press mention, review, and social media comment offers insight into the public’s perceptions of your brand. The key is knowing how to use it.

MagicBrief gives marketers the inspiration and analytics tools to create ads that shape perception and build trust. By turning real audience insights into high-performing creatives, you’re not just reacting to the conversation - you’re leading it!

Here’s what we offer:

💡 See What Works. Explore top-performing ads and see how brands turn reputation into conversions.

🛠 Turn Insights into Creatives. Track competitor marketing strategies, and craft ads that answer real audience concerns.

📊 Optimise and Test. Link your ad account to measure how reputation-driven messaging improves ad performance in real time.

Reputation isn’t just about managing perception. It’s about owning the conversation. With MagicBrief, insights and creative strategy to turn brand trust into real revenue. Book a Demo today and start building ads that convert.

‍